Barbelo
NewEconomicThinking
NewEconomicThinking·February 26, 2020

Karl Polanyi's Legacy and the Genesis of Great Financialization

Watch on YouTube

Summary

This episode features the speaker, Karl Polanyi's daughter, discussing her role in preserving and promoting her father's intellectual legacy. Following her mother's passing, she took on the responsibility of managing Polanyi's literary works, leading to the organization of a centenary conference in Budapest in 1986. This period coincided with the rise of neoliberalism under Thatcher and Reagan, which spurred her and her colleague Marguerite Mendel to establish the Polanyi Institute at Concordia University, ensuring continued support for her father's scholarly work and its relevance to contemporary issues.

The speaker recounts her personal journey with Polanyi's seminal work, "The Great Transformation," noting that its profound impact on her came later in life, particularly from the 1980s onwards, mirroring a broader appreciation among social scientists. This deeper engagement with her father's ideas, combined with observations of economic trends, led her to coin the term "great financialization." She describes this phenomenon as the disturbing growth of the financial sector—finance, insurance, real estate—and various financial assets, including derivatives, which she argues has been the primary driver of the global economy for the past three decades, surpassing trade and technology.

She elaborates on the destructive impact of great financialization, particularly on the classic American corporation. What once produced and sold products, employed many, and satisfied consumers, has transformed into entities driven by financial conglomerates and the maximization of shareholder value. This shift, she contends, is a profound financialization of corporate purpose. The concept extends beyond corporations, permeating society itself, as Polanyi's work suggests that an economy driving society will see society reflect that economy.

Consequently, households have become increasingly financialized, dependent on finance through pension funds, mortgage indebtedness, and student loans. Governments, especially in Europe, are similarly dependent on bond markets, with some even losing the ability to print their own money due to the Euro. This pervasive financialization fosters a societal short-termism, closely linked to information technology, consumerism, and a widespread desire for immediate results, impacting not just young people but society at large.

Key Quotes

"I really considered that I will now concern myself with the legit literary legacy of my father and I have been doing that ever since."
"I was very conscious of the rise of neoliberalism and in its worst manifestation this was the era of Thatcher and Reagan respectively implementing those kind of policies abolishing progressive taxation and all the rest of them you know what they are"
"I must have read the great transformation but it was not the kind of revealing event that it was for many other people."
"I coined this phrase of great financialization"
"it is not trade or technology but rather finance... that has been driving the world the global economy for the past three decades"
"in my view it has for instance destroyed the what used to be the classic American corporation"
"increasingly these shareholders are financial conglomerates the various kinds pension funds investment funds other kinds of financial funds and it has has come with the amongst maximizing of shareholder value as as the metric of success herbal conservation what could be more financial than that"
"as Palani explained it will if an economy is driving the society the society then reflects and that our societies our households they become financial eyes"
"you have an economy that is increasingly as I say financialized in a society that is increasingly short term news and that goes along with the information technology and business with the consumerism and the shortest desire somehow of young people particularly to have immediate results"

Concepts

Themes

  • Legacy and intellectual stewardship
  • Critique of neoliberal economic policies
  • The pervasive influence of finance
  • Societal transformation through economic shifts
  • Intergenerational intellectual influence
  • The evolution of capitalism
  • Short-term vs. long-term societal goals
  • Economic determinism of social structures

Related to:

Economics Insights

Key Figures

  • Karl Polanyi
  • Ilona Polanyi
  • Marguerite Mendel
  • Margaret Thatcher
  • Ronald Reagan

Economic Mechanisms

  • Shareholder value maximization
  • Financialization
  • Progressive taxation abolition
  • Bond market dependence
  • Derivatives trading

Historical Context

  • Post-WWI Hungarian Revolution (1918)
  • 1980s rise of neoliberalism
  • 1950s-1970s classic American corporation era
  • Past three decades of global finance dominance

Institutions Mentioned

  • Concordia University
  • Polanyi Institute
  • Hungarian Embassy in Ottawa
  • European bond markets

Geographical Focus

  • Hungary
  • Budapest
  • Ottawa
  • Vienna
  • McGill
  • Europe
  • Advanced countries
  • Global economy
  • America

Similar Episodes